Current:Home > reviewsGarth Brooks wants to move his sexual assault case to federal court. How that could help the singer. -Quantum Capital Pro
Garth Brooks wants to move his sexual assault case to federal court. How that could help the singer.
View
Date:2025-04-12 00:36:55
Garth Brooks' lawyers are trying to consolidate the two lawsuits he is a part of that turn on the same set of disputed allegations — whether he sexually assaulted his hair and makeup artist in 2019.
Brooks' lawyers filed a motion on Nov. 1 to move the sexual assault lawsuit brought against him from California state court to federal court, and it was assigned to a federal judge on Friday.
That same day, Brooks' lawyers asked U.S. District Judge Michael W. Fitzgerald to dismiss his accuser's claims and direct her to refile them in Mississippi federal court — where Brooks preemptively sued the woman and claimed she was blackmailing him — or at least to pause the California case until the Mississippi case is resolved.
Brooks' former makeup artist sued him in October under the alias "Jane Roe" and claimed Brooks raped and sexually assaulted her in 2019. Roe claims that the rape occurred when she traveled with Brooks to L.A. for a Grammy tribute performance.
Brooks filed a lawsuit on Sept. 13 under the name John Doe in Mississippi federal court, preemptively asking a judge to declare sexual misconduct allegations against him untrue.
Need a break? Play the USA TODAY Daily Crossword Puzzle.
Brooks' lawyers argue it'd be more efficient if the competing claims were handled in the same court.
"[If] Brooks succeeds in the Mississippi Action by proving that Roe’s allegations of assault are false, Roe will not prevail in this action because it requires her to prove that the exact same allegations are true," Brooks' lawyers wrote. "The parties should not be required to conduct overlapping discovery here and in the Mississippi Action simultaneously. And this Court should not be thrust into a race with the Southern District of Mississippi to decide the critical factual issues that are dispositive of both actions."
The Tennessean, as part of the USA TODAY Network, requested comment from Brooks' attorneys. It was not immediately answered via phone or email.
According to Jane Roe's attorneys, Brooks' efforts to move the case are an intimidation tactic.
“This is just more of the same bullying and intimidation Garth Brooks has used from the moment he learned our client intended to hold him accountable," said Jeanne M. Christensen, a lawyer representing Jane Roe. "We look forward to getting before a jury and reaching the merits of this case.”
Brooks has denied the allegations against him and said that Roe is extorting him. And he is asking to be awarded damages for defamation and emotional distress.
Brooks recently announced the final shows of his sold-out Garth Brooks/Plus One residency at The Colosseum at Caesars Palace in Las Vegas would be in March. He next performance in Vegas is in December.
Leaving the country?Garth Brooks, Trisha Yearwood have discussed living in Ireland amid rape claims, he says
Why did Garth Brooks move his case to federal court?
Brooks attorneys wrote Friday that they want to litigate his case against her, and her case against him, in the same court. Presumably, moving his accuser's lawsuit against him from California state court to federal court in California put them closer to doing that.
There are a number of other strategic reasons Brooks' team may have opted to move the case against him to federal court, says Kate Mangels, a partner at the Los Angeles law firm Kinsella Holley Iser Kump Steinsapi
Even if the California and Mississippi cases aren't handled on the same docket, they are now "both governed by the federal rules, so there's more consistency between those cases."
Mangels also said that federal court is thought to move faster, judges may be quicker to dismiss cases and the jury pool pulls from a wider geographic area. "You might get a more rural jury pool, which potentially Garth Brooks' lawyers think would be more kinder to him," she said.
In California state court for civil cases, the jury needs to be unanimous. In federal court in civil cases, only three-fourths of the jury needs to agree to reach a verdict.
Mangels said it is possible for Roe to try and have the case moved back to state court, but that Roe's team would have to make a strong showing as to why the case would be more appropriate in state court.
Garth Brooks accusations:The news is a big disappointment − and an important reminder
What has happened in the Garth Brooks, Jane Roe cases since original lawsuits
After Jane Roe went public with her allegations and the lawsuit, Brooks' team named his accuser in a document later in October. USA TODAY generally does not name alleged victims of sexual assault.
Brooks' legal team said that his accuser's lawyers named Brooks to CNN before the Mississippi court could rule whether Brooks could continue the case under the John Doe pseudonym, and that she "short-circuited the judicial process."
Due to Roe filing the case in California, publicly naming Brooks and "Roe’s willingness to proceed under her name in this litigation," Brooks' filing said, he amended his complaint to include his accuser's real name.
Roe's team responded by filing sanctions against Brooks for his disclosure of her name, also filing an emergency motion to redact her name or seal the amended complaint.
"In revealing our client’s name, Brooks exhibits precisely the type of retaliatory and abusive behavior that compels sexual assault victims to remain silent," a representative from Roe's team said in an email to The Tennessean, part of the USA TODAY network, on Oct. 9.
On Oct. 18, lawyers representing Brooks and his accuser met in Mississippi at the Thad Cochran United States Courthouse, "to argue their positions on two court motions both parties, at times, viewed as an attack on their clients," according to the Clarion Ledger. The judge did not issue a decision on that date.
Audrey Gibbs is a music reporter for The Tennessean. You can reach her at [email protected].
veryGood! (1628)
Related
- Finally, good retirement news! Southwest pilots' plan is a bright spot, experts say
- Watch these fabulous feline stories on International Cat Day
- Christina Hall Jokes About Finding a 4th Ex-Husband Amid Josh Hall Divorce
- American Sam Watson sets record in the speed climb but it's not enough for Olympic gold
- California DMV apologizes for license plate that some say mocks Oct. 7 attack on Israel
- Ohio woman claims she saw a Virgin Mary statue miracle, local reverend skeptical
- Team USA's Grant Holloway wins Olympic gold medal in 110 hurdles: 'I'm a fireman'
- NYC driver charged with throwing a lit firework into a utility truck and injuring 2 workers
- Average rate on 30
- The Ultimate Guide to Microcurrent Therapy for Skin: Benefits and How It Works (We Asked an Expert)
Ranking
- Working Well: When holidays present rude customers, taking breaks and the high road preserve peace
- NYC’s ice cream museum is sued by a man who says he broke his ankle jumping into the sprinkle pool
- Utah bans 13 books at schools, including popular “A Court of Thorns and Roses” series, under new law
- Julianne Moore’s Son Caleb Freundlich Engaged to Kibriyaá Morgan
- SFO's new sensory room helps neurodivergent travelers fight flying jitters
- Teen Mom Stars Amber Portwood and Gary Shirley’s Daughter Leah Looks All Grown Up in Rare Photo
- 'Euphoria' star Hunter Schafer says co-star Dominic Fike cheated on her
- 'It Ends with Us': All the major changes between the book and Blake Lively movie
Recommendation
Israel lets Palestinians go back to northern Gaza for first time in over a year as cease
Handlers help raise half-sister patas monkeys born weeks apart at an upstate New York zoo
Police Weigh in on Taylor Swift's London Concerts After Alleged Terror Attack Plot Foiled in Vienna
PHOTO COLLECTION: AP Top Photos of the Day Thursday August 8, 2024
Meta releases AI model to enhance Metaverse experience
Rain, wind from Tropical Storm Debby wipes out day 1 of Wyndham Championship
Ohio woman claims she saw a Virgin Mary statue miracle, local reverend skeptical
Morocco topples Egypt 6-0 to win Olympic men’s soccer bronze medal